Man Box

Me Too and the Bro Culture: Giving a Voice to Oppression

I’m going to take a step outside the book and my writing to make a note about something that I think is really important. Hey, this is my blog, and I can pretty much do whatever I want here, right? In case this looks like an advertisement for my book, I want to note that I only devoted a few sentences to gender equality in the book. I tried to make female characters important, and avoided making them objects, but this really isn’t about the book, and the book isn’t about this.

I’ve been working in the past few months with a women’s group at my company. They are an incredible group of people that are doing their best to help make my company a welcoming, safe, fair, equal, and better place for women. I’ve been attending meetings for several years and this fall I signed on as a director of the Men as Allies program.

The research in this area is incredible. The vast majority of men want to help, for no other reason than it is the right thing to do. Most men want the world to be fair, and would be willing to sacrifice some of their privilege to get there. Privilege, however, is not often visible to the people who have it. We take for granted a number of freedoms of which we are not even aware. This list doesn’t even begin, but think, when was the last time you walked into a meeting and you were the only person of your gender in the room? How often do you get interrupted in meetings? What is the general make-up of your company in terms of gender? I mean if you dig deeper beyond the top line summary of numbers. What if you remove female-dominated departments like human resources from the total? The fact is, despite our best efforts, workplaces in general are not fair and equal. We want them to be, most of us, we are trying to get them there, but they aren’t there yet. I know my company and many others are trying, and that is commendable. I want to help.

I volunteered to be a director because I thought I could use my voice as a man to get the message out about the efforts of this group. I thought they could use me as a megaphone, as a symbol, as an example. I didn’t know exactly what I was going to do, mostly I wanted to be a tool that the fantastic women running this group could use to help advance equality. I knew I would have to do some work, but I didn’t really have a clear picture yet.

I’ve learned a lot.

In the past few months I’ve read hundreds of papers on the subject, watched videos and TED talks, and last week I was allowed to attend a Catalyst conference specifically about Men Advocating Real Change. This conference was nothing like I expected. I thought they would talk mostly about what we can do to help women: Tips and tricks for advancing and correcting the culture at our companies. There was a little bit about that from some excellent leaders at P&G and Chevron, but it was more focused on men. A lot of what they said really hit home for me, and I’m going to make an effort to step out of my “man box.” The biggest thing that I took away is that if men want to help, to truly make a difference, we have to recognize and change ourselves and our own culture.

There were some excellent speakers, one of the subjects was about the “Man Box.” I strongly encourage you to watch it. It is excellent, moving, eye-opening, and beautiful.

Tony Porter – A Call to Men

This is a scary time in which we’re living. Very scary. I’m not ashamed to admit it, I am terrified right now.

  • I’m scared of Covid-19 – we’re doing everything we can as a family to protect ourselves and our communities, but it is scary as hell.
  • I’m afraid of constant fighting: the way that communication, negotiation, and understanding have been replaced by arguing, name-calling, and echo-chambers. There is common, middle ground.
  • I’m scared of the world that my son and daughter are inherit, in so many ways. Economically, environmentally, socially, etc.
  • I’m scared that I’m not a good enough dad, and that my kids aren’t going to have the best possible life.
  • I’m scared that I could lose my job, and that it’d be hard to find another one.
  • I’m scared of failing to provide for my family the best possible life.
  • I’m scared, for my kids, that something could happen to me

These are just the ones that came to mind. I’m a man, I’m afraid, and that’s ok.

Men:

  • It is ok to have feelings;
  • It is ok to need connections with people;
  • It is ok to be afraid, sad, happy, worried, angry, etc.;
  • It is ok to be a woman;
  • It is ok to be gay;
  • It is ok to be weak;
  • It is ok to cry;
  • It is ok to follow, or not to dominate others;
  • It is ok to be a man.

You are welcome to disagree with anything that I say. I encourage it wholeheartedly. As with my writing, I only hope to make things better and to encourage meaningful discussion. I’d love to hear your thoughts. What are you scared of?

May your world always grow,

BW

4 thoughts on “Man Box

  1. I agree on most points, including how you define the man box. Although all people should be treated with kindness, God created men as men, and women as women. He designed one man and one woman for marriage and procreation.

    There are certain lifestyles people practice that as a Christian, I cannot agree with. I have nothing personally against them. It is as simple as me acknowledging that it is wrong in the same way I would say stealing or adultery is wrong.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Hi Petrina,

      Thank you for sharing your opinion. I appreciate you sharing your it openly and fairly. I agree that all people should be treated with kindness, I disagree that homosexual lifestyles are inherently wrong.

      I don’t wish to start an argument. I trust that you’ve heard many counter arguments, as I have your Christian ones. I’m more certain that neither of us are likely to change each others minds based on an online discussion (or likely any discussion – these being deeply held personal convictions.)

      I think that maybe we can agree, however, that there are all kinds of men, from very macho and traditionally “masculine” to types that are more “effeminate” types that don’t nicely fall into the man box. The point that I want to convey is that narrowly defining men by the classic man-box definition, which is predicated on what men should not be (women or gay) makes for a toxic culture where men struggle to form meaningful connections and it contributes to a number of societal issues.

      Thank you again for your comment Petrina. I mean it when I say I encourage discussion wholeheartedly, and I thank you for taking the time to read the post and to think about it.

      BW

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Good observations Brett. Now we simply need more men to listen to what you have said, and written. Conversations can be so difficult, when egos get in the way. Expressing feelings, within reason, is important, and much better than either partner storing up hurts, and losses, and then taking that hurt, and loss out on their partner, or kids.. I’ve had conversations, with several men, over the years, about the differences between men, and women. There is no question that there are differences, but both sexes need to work with those differences. Both sexes need to know those differences.

    The best book, I have ever read, witjh amazingly helpful hints, was Tom Grey’s book: Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus.. Up to that point, after a 28 year marriage, I had no idea that we thought so differently

    I believe men of your generation are more able to express feelings, than those of my generation. That, at least, is a darn good start. Unfortunately, the COVID situation is hitting many, terribly hard ,with job losses, working from home, parents in home care, staying in bubbles,, catching the disease, and on, and on. So many have lost jobs, and wonder how they’re going to pay rent. More are using food banks, and drinking. The normal outlets, such as team sports, recreation centres, musical concerts, movies, etc school plays,. are not allowed, never mind the socializing that we all need. I know, from many, that online University is not something they care for.

    I feel I am in the best possible place, on Vancouver Island, with few cases, wide open spaces, and being retired. My generation grew up in simpler times, safe, and enjoyable. The World has changed, and not for the better. Having families do well, in such trying times is tough, and coming out of the man box is a good, first step.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s